Current:Home > FinanceFederal appeals court rebuffs claims of D.C. jury bias in Jan. 6 case -Elevate Capital Network
Federal appeals court rebuffs claims of D.C. jury bias in Jan. 6 case
View
Date:2025-04-15 01:55:06
Washington — A federal appeals court in Washington upheld the conviction of a former New York City Police Department officer who was charged for his actions on Jan. 6, 2021, after he claimed that he couldn't get an impartial jury in Washington, D.C.
The unanimous three-judge panel for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit said in a ruling Tuesday that defendant Thomas Webster was wrong when he argued that the jury pool in the District of Columbia was too Democratic, too tied to the federal government and too surrounded by news coverage of the Capitol attack to produce 12 unbiased jurors who would decide his case.
Webster sought to have his case moved out of the nation's capital, raising concerns about political bias by the jury pool, but a federal district court denied his request.
In an opinion authored by Judge Patricia Millett, the judges found that nothing in the record suggested that the jury pool had preconceived notions about Webster or knew who he was. They also determined that he failed to show that the district's jury pool is incapable of producing fair juries for people facing charges that stem from the Jan. 6 attack.
"Webster asserts that the District overwhelmingly voted for President Biden and historically votes for Democratic candidates. That may be," Millett wrote. "But the political inclinations of a populace writ large say nothing about an individual's ability to serve impartially in adjudicating the criminal conduct of an individual."
Millett, appointed by former President Barack Obama, was joined by Judges Gregory Katsas and Neomi Rao, both selected by former President Donald Trump.
The judges rejected Webster's reliance on a poll that purported to measure the sentiments of the D.C. jury pool, which concluded 400 registered voters in the city had a negative impression of those arrested in connection with the events of Jan. 6.
"Webster's focus on the jury pool's opinion of January 6th and its perpetrators misses the point," Millett wrote. "We expect jurors to view significant criminal events in their hometown with an unapproving eye, whether it is the January 6th attack on the Capitol, a murder, or an armed robbery spree. Generalized disapproval of criminal conduct — even the specific conduct at issue in a defendant's case — says nothing about a juror's ability to be impartial in deciding whether a particular individual committed a crime or not."
The panel said that the jury-selection process for Webster's case involved an "exacting search," in which potential jurors were screened with 21 questions that included their ties to the U.S. Capitol and knowledge about the Jan. 6 attack and feelings about Trump or his supporters that could impact their impartiality.
Prospective jurors then faced additional questions asked in-person and under oath.
In addition to upholding Webster's conviction, the panel affirmed his 10-year prison sentence.
Numerous Jan. 6 defendants have asked to have their cases moved out of D.C. on grounds that they believe the jury pool is tainted by bias, though they've failed to persuade federal judges overseeing their prosecutions. Trump, too, has claimed that he would not get an impartial jury in the nation's capital, where he faces four charges stemming from his alleged efforts to thwart the transfer of presidential power after the 2020 election. The former president pleaded not guilty to all counts.
Soon after he was indicted in August 2023, Trump's lawyer told "Face the Nation" that he would seek to have the case moved out of Washington and suggested West Virginia would be a better location. But they have not yet formally requested a new venue, and proceedings have been on hold since December while Trump seeks to have the entire indictment tossed out on immunity grounds. That issue is now before the Supreme Court.
Webster was among the crowd of Trump supporters who attended the rally outside the White House on Jan. 6 and marched to the Capitol. Wearing body armor and carrying a Marine Corps flag, he confronted police officers outside the Capitol and was involved in an altercation with a member of the Metropolitan Police Department, according to court papers.
Webster was accused of charging the officer, knocking him to the ground and pushing his gas mask into his face. The two men broke apart after a roughly 10-second struggle, according to filings.
A grand jury in Washington indicted Webster on five felony counts, including assaulting an officer using a dangerous weapon, and one misdemeanor. A jury then found him guilty on all counts and he received a 120-month sentence.
Melissa QuinnMelissa Quinn is a politics reporter for CBSNews.com. She has written for outlets including the Washington Examiner, Daily Signal and Alexandria Times. Melissa covers U.S. politics, with a focus on the Supreme Court and federal courts.
TwitterveryGood! (11)
Related
- NCAA hands former Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh a 4-year show cause order for recruiting violations
- Rookie police officer who was fatally shot in Arizona died on duty like his dad did 18 years earlier
- Messi joins Argentina for Copa América: His stats show he's ready for another title run
- Intelligence chairman says US may be less prepared for election threats than it was four years ago
- Your Wedding Guests Will Thank You if You Get Married at These All-Inclusive Resorts
- Hawaii's Kilauea volcano erupts in remote part of national park with low eruptive volume, officials say
- Search for climbers missing in Canada's Garibaldi Park near Whistler stymied by weather, avalanche threat
- Florida Panthers, Edmonton Oilers facing off in Stanley Cup Final. What to know
- Spooky or not? Some Choa Chu Kang residents say community garden resembles cemetery
- Lenny Kravitz Hints at Daughter Zoë Kravitz and Channing Tatum's Wedding Date
Ranking
- 51-year-old Andy Macdonald puts on Tony Hawk-approved Olympic skateboard showing
- Giant Food stores in D.C. area ban duffel bags to thwart theft
- Kentucky governor unveils rental housing projects for region still recovering from 2021 tornadoes
- USPS workers are attacked by dogs every day. Here are the U.S. cities with the most bite attacks.
- 'Meet me at the gate': Watch as widow scatters husband's ashes, BASE jumps into canyon
- Stock market today: Asian shares decline after report shows US manufacturing contracted in May
- After guilty verdict, Trump will appear on the ballot in the last presidential primaries of 2024
- Janis Paige, star of Hollywood and Broadway, dies at 101
Recommendation
How breaking emerged from battles in the burning Bronx to the Paris Olympics stage
Rodeo Star Spencer Wright's 3-Year-Old Son Levi Dies After Toy Tractor Accident
Cyndi Lauper announces farewell tour, documentary: 'Right now this is the best I can be'
Jack Black responds to students' request to attend 'School of Rock' musical production
British swimmer Adam Peaty: There are worms in the food at Paris Olympic Village
Biden executive order restricting asylum processing along U.S. border expected on Tuesday
Group says it intends to sue US agencies for failing to assess Georgia plant’s environmental impact
These 23 Pottery Barn Teen Items Work as Home Decor Gems for Modern Adults: Finds Starting at $4.99